South Africa’s forex trading industry is one of the most developed in Africa, governed by a strong regulatory framework under the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA). Local and international traders have access to a wide range of brokers—but not all brokers operate the same way. This article breaks down the types of forex brokers in South Africa, based on trading model, regulation, execution method, and account structure.

Regulated vs. Unregulated Forex Brokers

✅ FSCA-Regulated Brokers

These brokers are authorised to operate in South Africa and must:

• Segregate client funds
• Submit to compliance audits
• Offer transparent pricing
• Be listed on the FSCA’s official register

Examples:

• HotForex South Africa (HFM ZA) – FSP No. 46632
• FXTM South Africa – FSP No. 46614
• Khwezi Trade – FSP No. 44816

❌ Unregulated or Offshore Brokers

These brokers may operate from jurisdictions like Seychelles, Belize, or St. Vincent and accept South African clients without FSCA authorisation. While often offering high leverage and bonuses, they come with higher risk and no local recourse.

Examples:

• Exness (FSA Seychelles)
• FBS (IFSC Belize)
• Octa (Unregulated)

Broker Types by Execution Model

1. Market Maker (Dealing Desk)

• How it works: Broker acts as the counterparty to your trade
• Pros: Fixed spreads, fast execution
• Cons: Conflict of interest, slippage in volatile markets
• Best For: Beginner traders with small accounts

SA Examples: CM Trading, some FXCM accounts

2. STP (Straight Through Processing)

• How it works: Trades routed directly to liquidity providers with no dealing desk
• Pros: No broker interference, tighter spreads
• Cons: Variable spreads, possible slippage
• Best For: Intermediate traders, swing traders

SA Examples: FXTM, Khwezi Trade

3. ECN (Electronic Communication Network)

• How it works: Clients trade directly with a network of liquidity providers
• Pros: Raw spreads (as low as 0.0 pips), full depth of market
• Cons: Commission charged per trade, higher minimum deposit
• Best For: Scalpers, algo traders, institutional clients

SA Examples: HotForex Zero Account, international brokers like IC Markets

Broker Types by Account Structure

1. Standard Account Brokers

• Spreads included in pricing
• No commission
• Ideal for casual or beginner traders

Popular In SA: XM, FXPesa (via Executive Account)

2. Raw Spread or Zero Account Brokers

• Tight spreads (0.0–0.3 pips)
• Commissions charged separately
• Used by high-frequency traders

Popular In SA: HotForex Zero, Exness Zero, Tickmill Pro

3. Cent or Micro Account Brokers

• Trade micro lots (0.01)
• Very low deposit requirement
• Great for learning risk management

Popular In SA: FBS, RoboForex

Local vs. International Brokers

Most Common Types of Brokers in South Africa

1. CMA-Regulated Market Makers: e.g., CM Trading
2. STP Brokers With FSCA Licence: e.g., Khwezi Trade
3. International ECN Brokers: e.g., IC Markets, Exness
4. Offshore Bonus Brokers: e.g., FBS, RoboForex, XM (IFSC entity)
5. ZAR-Account Local Brokers: e.g., HotForex SA, FXTM SA

Key Takeaways

• South Africa offers both FSCA-regulated brokers and access to offshore brokerages
• Most brokers operate as market makers, STP, or ECN, each with unique benefits
• FSCA brokers offer legal protection but limit leverage and promotions
• Traders seeking high leverage or bonuses often use offshore brokers at their own risk
• Always verify a broker’s regulatory status on the FSCA website

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the safest type of forex broker in South Africa?

FSCA-regulated STP or ECN brokers are considered the safest due to regulatory oversight, transparent pricing, and fair execution.

Are ECN brokers available in South Africa?

Yes. Brokers like HotForex, Tickmill, and IC Markets offer ECN accounts to South African clients, although some are offshore-licensed.

Can South Africans use offshore forex brokers?

Yes, but at their own risk. Offshore brokers offer higher leverage and bonuses but are not protected by South African law.

What is the difference between a market maker and an ECN broker?

Market makers set their own prices and may trade against clients. ECN brokers connect traders directly to liquidity providers with raw spreads and commission fees.

How can I verify if a forex broker is FSCA-regulated?

Go to www.fsca.co.za and search for the broker’s FSP number or company name to confirm its regulatory status.

Please leave this field empty

What’s The Best Broker, Educator & Prop Firm?

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.